A resistance spot weld peel-test report is useful only when the tested sheet stack, weld identity, test method and acceptance rule are clear. A visible button or a photograph of torn metal is evidence of a failure mode, but it is not a universal certificate of joint strength. Buyers should distinguish the surface electrode mark, the observed fracture feature and the fused weld region before approving a batch of fabricated parts.
This guide addresses the acceptance record for spot-welded sheet metal. It complements process planning rather than providing welding-machine settings. For sheet metal fabrication inquiries to FUMING, specify the joint’s service requirements and the evidence expected from test coupons or production samples.
Separate a surface mark from the weld beneath it
An indentation shows where an electrode contacted a surface; it does not directly reveal the entire fused region between the sheets. TWI’s guidance on surface marking in resistance spot welding explains that nugget formation occurs at the sheet interface and that surface marking is a separate practical concern. A cosmetic photograph should therefore not be presented as a nugget measurement.
Likewise, terminology must remain consistent after destructive testing. Identify whether a reported diameter refers to a pulled-out button, a feature on the fracture surface or a fused region observed in a prepared section. These observations are not interchangeable merely because each is roughly circular. The applicable test procedure determines how the feature is measured and reported.
Ask for a sketch or annotated photograph showing the measurement locations and specimen orientation. Preserve the unedited photograph as well. Avoid placing a ruler over the feature so that it hides the boundary being assessed. The purpose is reproducibility: another reviewer should be able to understand what was measured without guessing from a cropped close-up.

Define a representative specimen
Record material grades, actual thicknesses, coating condition, number of sheets and their order in the stack. A coupon made from convenient scrap may demonstrate that the machine can create a weld, but it may not represent a production joint. A coating change or a different sheet combination can change the conditions at the interface even when the drawing dimensions look unchanged.
Also identify overlap, weld spacing, edge distance, access and welding sequence. If the coupon differs from the real assembly, state the difference and explain why the evidence remains relevant. Do not quietly extrapolate a result from an accessible flat strip to a tightly formed enclosure where electrodes approach at a different angle or fit-up is harder to control.
Maintain a link from each specimen to the production setup, drawing revision and sampling point. A useful record might identify a start-up sample, a sample after electrode maintenance, or a sample after a material change. The quality plan should define when these events require checks; this article does not prescribe a universal sampling frequency.
Read failure mode together with the agreed criterion
TWI’s discussion of interface failures in resistance spot welds identifies both inadequate fusion and low weld-zone ductility as possible contributors. An interface failure therefore deserves investigation, but its cause cannot be identified from the words “failed peel test” alone. Material, process history and the test observations all matter.
Record whether the specimen shows pullout, interface separation, a mixed mode or a failure elsewhere in the sheet. Use the terminology defined by the applicable procedure. For an irregular feature, record the required dimensions separately rather than selecting the largest visible span and calling it the weld diameter. Keep photographs traceable to the same individual weld numbers as the data table.
The acceptance rule should come from the responsible drawing, contract or applicable standard. Do not transplant a generic diameter relationship from a training page into a customer specification without checking material, stack and test conditions. Where the contract is silent, resolve the criterion before the test rather than deciding afterward that the observed result looks satisfactory.
Build a report that can be reviewed remotely
| Record field | What to capture | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Specimen identity | Part, revision, lot and individual weld numbers | Connects photographs and measurements to the tested item |
| Sheet stack | Grades, thicknesses, coating and order | Shows whether the coupon represents production |
| Process reference | Approved schedule and equipment/setup identification | Supports investigation without relying on memory |
| Test procedure | Method, orientation, preparation and revision | Makes the test reproducible |
| Observed result | Failure mode, specified dimensions and clear images | Separates observation from interpretation |
| Disposition | Criterion, pass/fail decision and reviewer | Documents the basis for accepting or holding the lot |
Include departures from the test procedure and explain how they affect interpretation. If a specimen slips, tears at a grip or is damaged during preparation, do not silently substitute its result for a valid test. Retain the original entry, identify why it was excluded if exclusion is justified, and connect any replacement sample to the same investigation.
Keep this evidence with the project’s quality assurance records. A summary spreadsheet can make review efficient, but it should link to the original photographs and measurements. The final acceptance line should not conceal unresolved observations or remove failed specimens from the visible sample population.

Know when another test is needed
A peel test and a load-measuring test answer different questions. A fracture observation does not, by itself, supply a tensile-shear load or a fatigue life. TWI’s overview of weld testing methods distinguishes destructive and non-destructive approaches. Select the test that addresses the specified joint requirement rather than treating all test labels as equivalent.
If the application needs a force-displacement result, define specimen geometry, fixture arrangement, loading direction and the applicable test method. If the question concerns fusion geometry or internal condition, a prepared section may provide different evidence. Neither addition should be ordered automatically; explain the unresolved engineering question and request the method that can answer it.
Appearance remains a separate requirement. An acceptable destructive test does not approve excessive marking on a customer-facing panel. Document cosmetic zones and any post-weld surface finishing constraints independently. Do not polish or coat away a defect simply to make the photograph resemble an approved appearance sample.
What to do when a coupon fails
Identify the potentially affected production interval using the last acceptable check and the event history. Preserve the failed specimen and its record. The responsible team should decide containment and additional sampling based on the agreed quality plan. A later passing coupon does not automatically explain or release all parts made before it.
Review changes in material, coating, fit-up, electrode condition and the approved welding schedule. Separate observed changes from hypotheses. If a corrective action is taken, record what changed and repeat the required validation under controlled conditions. Avoid changing several unrelated factors at once when doing so would make the cause impossible to establish.
For formed assemblies, compare the test specimen with the actual joint and revisit access, alignment and restraint. The welding fixture design guide provides broader fit-up context, although resistance spot welding requires its own suitable fixture and procedure.
Questions buyers often ask
Does a pulled-out button always prove acceptance?
No. It is an observation that must be evaluated against the specified material, test procedure and acceptance criteria. Report its dimensions and failure mode as required; do not replace the contractual rule with a visual impression.
Can a weld’s outer indentation be used as its nugget diameter?
Not as an assumed equivalent. The surface contact mark and the fused interface are different features. Identify the feature actually measured and use the method required by the inspection plan.
What should be included in a quotation request?
Provide material and coating specifications, sheet stack, joint drawing, appearance zones, production quantity and testing requirements. Send FUMING the proposed inspection record so the scope of sampling, destructive specimens and reporting can be agreed before production.



